Dianna Smiley llc

Bringing Strategy to Fundraising

  • Home
  • Services
  • Fundraising Insights
  • Endorsements
  • About Dianna
  • Contact

Photo by Dianna Smiley

Asking for a specific amount helps everyone

November 20, 2026 by Dianna Smiley in Board Members, Capital Campaign, Understanding Donors

This article assumes that your organization is having a capital campaign and using donor research/ wealth screening. However, the principles outlined apply to all gift conversations with major donors.

As your organization’s representative, are you able to graciously invite each of your campaign donors to consider giving or pledging a specific amount? 

If this is too scary, you need to get help. Being able to ask for a specific amount helps you raise larger gifts, increases your confidence and greatly bolsters your long-term results.

Before we talk about how to ask, let’s discuss what happens in a donor meeting when you don’t ask for a specific amount.

It’s confusing for the donor. Let’s say you’ve had two meetings and several email interactions with them already. In this meeting, as you talk about how much difference this project will make and how their support is needed, here are some of the thoughts the donor may be having:

  • How much do they want from me?

  • How much do they NEED from me?

  • If they don’t suggest how much would be helpful, does my gift even matter?

  • What if the amount I offer is not enough, or is wildly different from what they need?

In being non-specific about your ask (“whatever amount is significant to you…”), you are avoiding a concrete discussion in which you name an amount and the donor can respond. After all, in this meeting, you are the person who knows what your organization needs in this campaign.

When you do ask for a specific amount, the donor is free to respond in any way they want, ranging from, “That amount is probably more than we can give, but we will definitely make a gift. We were thinking more in the x to y range” to… “Let me (us) think about that. I’m not sure if we can do that, but we need a little time to consider it”…to “Yes, we will be pleased to do that” …to “Yes, we will do that, but we were also thinking about an additional gift.”

But what if they are offended, you may ask.

Well, no fund raiser I know has ever heard the dreaded response, “Are you kidding? How much money do you think we HAVE?!!”, or anything similar. It just doesn’t happen.

In fact, if the amount of your ask is higher than they can consider, the donor may even be flattered. More likely, however, they will just tell you than they can’t give that much, but they will consider a lower amount.

And your mutually respectful conversation with the donors continues, negotiating the amount, the asset they want to use, and timing of their gift. It’s all perfectly natural.

OK, so how do you make a specific ask?

First, ask for their permission to discuss a gift. As you ask for this meeting or very early in the meeting, say something like, “We’ve had some great discussions about this project, [first name], and we’d like to ask for your support. Is this a good time for us to talk specifically about your gift?”

They may say “No, now is not a good time.” Then you need to say, “What will be a good time for you? Let’s wait and talk then.” But this is unlikely if you’ve already had two meetings and several interactions with them about the project.

So…wait until they essentially say yes, and then say, “That’s great. We want to invite you to consider a gift of [specific dollar amount, not a range] for this project. Might that be something you would consider?”

Then be quiet. Don’t stare at them, but stay alert with a pleasant expression on your face.

Wait until they say something you can respond to.

You may think their answer is “No” even though they don’t actually say that. Listen carefully to their initial sentence and what follows. It might be any of the following (or a million other responses): 

  • “Not now.”

  • “This year is not good.”

  • “We’re trying to sell our business, and we can’t do anything until we see how that goes.”

  • “That’s more than we could do.”

  • “We are cash poor because of all the properties we own.”

None of the above responses is “No.”  In fact, you should be glad if a prospect utters any of the above responses. There’s lots to work with here, but you’ve got to be willing to ask the prospect at least one more question, if not several.

For example, to the comment, “We are cash poor because of all the properties we own,” you could say, “That’s interesting. Do you own any properties that you’d rather not have in your portfolio at this point?” More than likely, if the donor prospects have owned them for a long time, the answer will be yes, and then you can say, “We’d love to work with you to see if one of those properties might make a great gift to our campaign. Is that something you’d like to have us explore with you?”

Or if they say, “Not now,” the next thing you can say is “Tell me more about that. When might be a better time?”

And if they follow up with “We’re not sure,” you can say “We can check in with you again in about a month. How would that work for you?”

Over time, always keep the conversation going with your donors - before the ask until they’re ready for it, during the ask process, and beyond, as their engagement with your organization grows and they look for new ways to help you. They will feel great about the conversation and their participation with the mission of your group.

© 2026 Dianna Smiley LLC

November 20, 2026 /Dianna Smiley
fundraising, donor solicitation, donor relations
Board Members, Capital Campaign, Understanding Donors

  • Newer
  • Older

© 2024 Dianna Smiley LLC. All Rights Reserved.